Skip to content

GTA 6 Halifax Statue Choice: Should You Accept the Watch?

StoryPS5Xbox Series X|S Contains spoilers

By GTA EXP Team · Updated 21 Nov 2026

Quick answer

Give Halifax the statue and accept his watch to keep the full Dubious Provenance questline available. If you’ve just refused and his phone goes to voicemail, wait for his follow-up message, then call him about the appraisal and return to the store. Reconsider before Chapter 3 ends. [1][2]

Before you start

  • Story mode, Chapter 3
  • Complete Dealer’s Choice, then interact with the bag in the Bayside apartment closet. [2]
On this page

Should you give Halifax the statue or keep it?

Accept the offer if your aim is to play the whole questline and collect its rewards. PC Gamer also recommends handing it over straight away: refusing postpones the same route and means returning to Capri if you change your mind. [1]

If you’re wondering whether the statue is worth trading for a watch, Halifax is offering the watch as security while he gets the statue appraised. You’re agreeing to let him take it away for that job. [1]

Your choiceWhat happensBest for
Give Halifax the statue / accept the watchYou receive his watch and open the route to the later missions. [1][2]Playing the full questline.
Refuse / keep the statueYou keep it for now. If he won’t answer, wait for his follow-up message, then call about the appraisal.Delaying the decision.
Refuse and never call backThe callback expires at the end of Chapter 3, closing off Parts 2 and 3. [2]Skipping the optional follow-ups.

How to give Halifax the statue after refusing

Halifax goes to voicemail or the answering machine

Changed your mind straight after refusing, but Halifax isn’t picking up? Give him a little time. An immediate call can reach his answering machine; wait for his follow-up message, then try calling again.

  1. 1Wait for Halifax’s message in the group chat with Jason and Lucia. He says you can give him a call if you change your mind.
  2. 2Open your in-game phone’s contacts, select Halifax and call him after that message arrives.
  3. 3During the conversation, ask to have the statue appraised.
  4. 4Return to Evelyn Andrews Antiques in Capri and follow the renewed objective to hand over the statue.

Complete the optional “Call Halifax about the Statue” objective and handover before Chapter 3 ends. PowerPyx’s walkthrough gives that chapter boundary as the cutoff for keeping Parts 2 and 3 available; an initial refusal alone doesn’t close off the quest. [2]

Halifax’s group-chat message tells Jason and Lucia to call him if they change their minds about the statue appraisal.
Wait for this follow-up message if Halifax’s phone goes to the answering machine after you refuse.
Halifax selected in the in-game phone’s contacts list.
After the message arrives, call Halifax from Contacts and ask about the appraisal.

Which watch do you get, and how do you wear it?

Halifax gives you the Crowex Octane “Bobby Ambrose”. At a wardrobe, open Accessories, then Watches to equip it. It’s the reward for accepting his offer at the first meeting. [2][3]

How to start Dubious Provenance

  1. 1After Dealer’s Choice in Chapter 3, use Jason or Lucia to interact with the bag in the Bayside apartment closet. [2]
  2. 2Travel to Evelyn Andrews Antiques in Capri. Try the front door to head upstairs. [3]
  3. 3Evelyn turns down the appraisal; Halifax approaches you outside with his offer. [1]

How to find Halifax and enter the antique store

When the Find Halifax follow-up is available, return to the Capri shop. The quiet way in uses the rear window. [3]

  1. 1Wait for Evelyn to leave, then go around the back.
  2. 2Climb the stairs, jump to the lower roof and enter through the window above the air conditioner.
  3. 3Open the door for Jason. Search the desk drawer in the room’s north corner.
  4. 4Go to the motel next door. A resident points you to an upstairs room on the west side; interact with its door. [3]

Should you trust Halifax at the motel?

Choose Trust Halifax if you want Part 3. This is a second decision, separate from accepting his watch, and it keeps the final encounter available. For the fullest quest route, give him the statue at the first meeting and trust him again here. [4]

Part 3: find Halifax and finish the chase

  1. 1After Evelyn calls, return to her shop. Follow her lead to Maryam’s house in northwest Capri. [2]
  2. 2Follow Halifax’s boat on the Seashark. Close the gap and hold the displayed boarding prompt.
  3. 3After the crash, swim ashore. Take the waiting bicycle when the pursuit continues by golf cart.
  4. 4When control switches to Lucia, use Focus and shoot Halifax in the leg to stop him.
  5. 5Approach him, then use Lucia’s phone to call Jason. [3]

Do you get the statue back? Ending and rewards

If the follow-up call stays stuck

Save your progress, fully quit GTA 6 and reopen it without Quick Resume. An Xbox player waiting on Encrypted Hard Drive and the statue appraisal reports that queued missions arrived after doing this. Try it after the normal wait if your objective still has not advanced. [7]

GTA 6Dubious ProvenanceBenedict Halifaxstatue for watchaccept or refusegive or keep statuetrust HalifaxChapter 3Halifax voicemailHalifax answering machinestatue after refusing

Keep exploring

Browse more missions
Sources (7)
  1. PC Gamer — Should you give the statue to Benedict Halifax? (accessed 20 Nov 2026)
  2. PowerPyx — Dubious Provenance walkthrough (accessed 20 Nov 2026)
  3. GTA Base — Dubious Provenance mission guide (accessed 20 Nov 2026)
  4. Showgamer — Trusting Halifax, the statue and final rewards (accessed 20 Nov 2026)
  5. GTAEXP gameplay — Halifax’s message after refusing (accessed 20 Nov 2026)
  6. GTAEXP gameplay — Halifax in the phone contacts (accessed 20 Nov 2026)
  7. r/GTA6unmoderated — original Xbox stalled-call recovery report (accessed 21 Nov 2026)